Friday, December 5, 2008

India Irked! [Part I]

It has been nearly 10 days since the bedlam of terror hit our shores in a manner which stirred up a nation. We have been cowed down by a bunch of heartless individuals who in their insane judgment dreamed of disrupting the collective conscience of India. Yes, we are a scared society today and India is irked beyond measure.

Media Mayhem

While India bled in Bombay, the Media channels portrayed the 60-hour siege of Bombay as a real time movie which was broadcast into millions of homes across the world. And what a sham it was. While the heart bled and the eyes wept, the mind was raging with anger, disgust, dismay, disbelief, shock and hopelessness, all leading to a crescendo of emotional and apolitical outrage.

What started as ‘Breaking News’ ended up being a ‘Broken Affair’ with the very aspect of freedom that we were so proud of. The Free Press made a mockery of the very art of reporting. Top anchors with a pedigree of many awards inadvertently made us realize how crass insensitivities towards those affected, the lame verbiage that mocked at the anguish of the pain we were feeling as a nation, the inept attempts to rationalize, further deprecated the well intended reporting motives of the media.

It was an asinine race to be the ‘first to report’ and to have an ‘exclusive’. Frankly, I don’t think any Indian really cared about these trivialities. The media got their TRPs soaring but they ended up denigrating themselves and fell over each other to bring us the latest. Being professionals, didn’t they have the basic sense to refrain from beaming live pictures when the forces were fighting a faceless enemy within the corridors of the star hotels and people died earlier on the streets and railway platforms. What is ironic is that they actually reported that ‘they have been asked’ by the NSG to stop the live telecast as suddenly someone realized a ‘little too early’ that the media shouldn’t have been doing this in the very first place. Initial kudos turned into chaos. In the midst of all this relentless ‘me-first’ reporting, the media leapfrogged itself into ignominy.

The Media should be slammed for their insensitivity and over-sensationalism. They are for sure the masters of speculation and the stalwart anchors pitiably try hard to pin their guests down in a manner that is quite irascible. They are short on patience, don’t let people finish their points of view (I know they have to keep an eye on the clock) and are quite judgmental to the extent that they feel like the makers of ‘what is supposed to be done’.

Not once during the three days, did I see any of the leading channels talk about the fact that terror was unleashed on a nation and that India was under siege albeit at Bombay. The headlines screamed breaking news on ‘War on Mumbai’, ‘Mumbai Attacked’, ‘Maximum City under Siege’ etc. Should we be telling the custodians of free speech aka the Media that the nation comes first and everything else follows.

India was violated yet again. India was ripped apart once more. India was targeted. And the jealous neighbor is zealously involved!

Even after the perpetrators were snuffed out, the media went on about how Bombay has been crippled yet again and about how this city known for its ability to bounce back with to do so with elan. The thought of India was nowhere to be heard or seen while the anchors took turns lambasting everybody in their tired stupor to make an impression. And on whom?

Then, at the Taj minutes after the siege ended, there was more ineptness on display garbed in a cloak of impalpable disbelief. Barkha Dutt in her hoarse, anguished voice (which I am praying in retrospect that it was not put on), asks a fireman at the sea facing corner of the beleaguered Taj soon after the perpetrators were vanquished, “Please, please say something.” The fireman tries in vain to walk away while saying ‘No’ to her request. Ms Dutt has her way and points to the 1st floor and asks him about the fabric rope made out of bedsheets which is tied to the window – “Is this the way the trapped guests escaped?’ Obviously, the fireman nodded in agreement and then came the shocker of the century. Ms Dutt reported, “So this the way the fire department helped the guests get out of the Taj.” I am sure the fireman and his department folks would have cringed with utmost disrespect Ms Dutt for her intelligent inference.

For God’s sake, the very purpose of the Free Press is to give a voice to the common man, the average person of society and NOT put words in his mouth. They are meant to mediate and moderate, not to intervene and irritate. They are meant to make the unheard heard, the unseen seen, the unspoken spoken and not to desecrate the very spirit of the freedom of expression. They need to realize that they have a far greater responsibility than what they currently seem to fathom – towards the society, towards the nation and towards themselves as well.

As we bled, India invoked the resolve to fight back.

6 comments:

  1. Very thought provoking and well written. Indeed, in their mindless race for garnering TRPs, present day media seem to have shed all principles of journalism.

    ReplyDelete
  2. One of the important & missing aspect of the Mumbai massacre coverage is being uncovered here. Good to see someone is thinking through it. I liked reading it...upload the Part II.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I also wonder why we have satellite links to Pakistani panelists who never have anything sensible to say.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Praveen, you should've seen me fighting with all my colleagues here over this issue..My sister in law who works for NDTV in their production deptt, told us that even their entertainment reporters were told to go out to get as much live feed possible for this terror attack..Star news was even more disgusting when Deepak Chauraisa went to a family living behind the Taj and asked them if they liked what Star news did...the family also was no less and with a broad grin the grandmother tells Deepak "aap ne bahot achha kaam kiya ji"...felt like barging in through the screen only...Anyways, I have taken enough tensions and have reached the epitome of my fustration already! The channels still do not have anything else but Mumbai Carnage and celebrity views on terror attack (coming to you LIVE from MUMBAI)..I just hope somebody gives them a tight slap..!

    Kartika

    ReplyDelete
  5. Praveen, you should've seen me fighting with everybody here on this issue..every day you see people praising media for their wonderful contribution to this whole affair..what contribution, they have only been provoking people and are getting TRPs. I heard NDTV had told even its entertainment reporters to go out and get as much live feed as possible on this terror attack. And who gave them the right to term this whole carnage as India's 9/11, as if that attack on US has become a standard for measuring the impact of terror attacks; so if an attack falls short of that standard, it will not make people angry and it will not shake people's conscience. And even the people who say they're angry; I bet half of them have not been effected by anything that happened there. As long as your own people are safe, you're okay and you watch this whole thing as "News"..and may be not even that..Star news was even more disgusting, when Deepak Chaurasia asked this family living behind the Taj their opinion on how star news covered the terror attack and the family also was no less..With a broad grin, the grandmother tells Deepak "Aap ne bahot achha kaam kiya"..Disgusting...! I've seriously reached the epitome of my frustration already..there's nothing to stop them even now and all the channels are only talking about celebrity opinions (coming LIVE from MUMBAI)..Kartika

    ReplyDelete
  6. When the nation was watching the news about the Mumbai attacks live on television, i was trying to get some relevant news on rest of our nation…Sadly, nothing. Not even in local channels. And most of all…there is human anguish each time such acts are learned about. This time the coverage is more, the people in Mumbai are angry. Why? Because it happened in swanky localities?? Mumbai and some other cities in India were also affected before, but the reactions were subdued.
    ===============================================
    How very well described about yellow journalism. Unfortunately yet another time media has crossed the line,unless something like this happens no one realises that this is Wrong.
    The flip side to this sort of journalism got judgment to Jessica Lal and other cases. So, where does one draw the line??

    ReplyDelete